Abstract: Whether a cleaned condenser passes is judged on three lines at once. Tube cleanliness is read from an end-face inspection, a ball pass, a tube pull and a borescope; performance is read from terminal difference, vacuum and water-side pressure drop; paperwork is the lab sheet, the corrosion coupons and the photos. Physical water jetting has no code removal-rate figure, so the only defensible basis is a pre/post comparison at the same load; where a chemical stage is included, the quality figures come from GB/T 25146-2010, and the jetting itself is run to GB/T 26148-2025.
1. Fix the baseline first: compare against what, at which load
Before anything is measured, three baselines have to be on the table: the pre-cleaning terminal difference and vacuum (or back pressure) at the same unit load, with terminal difference taken as exhaust steam temperature minus cooling water outlet temperature; the cooling water pressure drop across the condenser; and the tube bundle record, meaning tube count, tube diameter, tube length, material and number of passes. Without them, a ball pass or a tube pull has nothing to be compared with.
The load conditions belong in the record too. Terminal difference is only comparable when cooling water temperature, cooling water flow and unit load are unchanged; in summer the figure is naturally larger, and a winter baseline will turn a good cleaning into a failure. If conditions did move, normalise to the same load and the same cooling water temperature first.
2. Tube cleanliness: what each of the four checks proves
An end-face and water box inspection shows bell-mouth scale, rolled-over tube ends, stray balls and debris, but it never shows the middle of a tube, so it is screening only. A photo is a record, not a conclusion. A borescope fills in that middle section and shows where scale and debris remain, at low cost and on a sampling basis, but it cannot separate thin slime from hard scale. The four checks complement each other; one alone is not enough.
A ball pass pushes sponge or rubber balls slightly under the tube ID through every tube. It proves the tube is open, not that the wall is clean, because a thin soft layer or slime lets a ball through unchanged.
A tube pull is the most direct evidence. Three to five tubes are pulled from the highest heat-flux zone, the air-cooling section and the run that needed the most plugs last time, and the sample is read for residual scale thickness and bell-mouth damage. It is destructive, so a plugging and re-tubing plan is agreed before the first tube comes out.
| Check | What it proves | Limit | When it is done |
|---|---|---|---|
| End-face and water box | Bell-mouth scale, rolled ends, debris | Tube middle not visible | Before and after cleaning |
| Ball pass | Tubes open, no blockage or plugs | Thin scale and slime pass | Acceptance after cleaning |
| Tube pull | Residual scale thickness, end damage | Destructive, needs plug plan | Disputed or critical units |
| Performance data | Whether heat transfer and vacuum really recovered | Sensitive to water temperature and air in-leakage | Same load after restart |
3. Performance: reading three curves without fooling yourself
A lower terminal difference means the heat transfer surface has recovered, a higher vacuum means steam-side evacuation has improved, and a lower water-side pressure drop means the flow path is open again. When all three move the same way, the conclusion is clean.
Terminal difference down but vacuum flat points to the steam side: failed vacuum tightness, a weak air ejector or poor gland sealing all hold vacuum down. Vacuum recovered but terminal difference flat points to the water side, where debris lodged at a partition or a water box corner short-circuits flow and shows up as a higher pressure drop.
Higher cooling water temperature and lower flow both make terminal difference look better than it is. Readings are taken in the same load band for the first two weeks after restart, as a trend over three samples rather than a single point.
4. Where the criteria come from: jetting has no code removal rate
This is the point most often written wrongly. GB/T 25146-2010, the acceptance specification for industrial equipment chemical cleaning quality, covers chemical cleaning; its Table 3 removal and cleaning rates apply to chemical work, and writing those numbers onto a pure jetting acceptance sheet has no basis. Field criteria for physical cleaning are three: pre/post terminal difference and vacuum at the same load, ball pass rate together with the tube pull, and the change in water-side pressure drop.
Where a chemical stage is included, as it often is for hard scale or copper tubes, the quality figures are taken from GB/T 25146-2010: measured corrosion rate on site not above 5 g/(m²·h) for carbon steel and 1.5 g/(m²·h) for stainless, corrosion mass not above 80 g/m² for carbon steel and 20 g/m² for stainless; removal rate not below 95% for carbonate, rust and oil deposits and not below 85% for sulphate, silicate and other deposit types; and where stainless parts are present, chloride in the cleaning solution not above 25 mg/L.
Chemical cleaning and film formation on power plant condensers follow DL/T 957-2017. Jetting safety follows GB/T 26148-2025: the specification applies from 10 MPa upwards, hand-held lance reaction force is calculated as F = 0.745·q·√p and kept at or below 200 N, hose service life is limited to 4 years and flexible lances to 2 years, the protective sleeve is at least 500 mm long, tube ends are pre-flushed 100 mm to 200 mm before lance cleaning, and the anti-withdrawal device sits within 3 cm of the tube sheet.
5. When the result falls short: coverage problem or not a cleaning problem
Rolled-over tube ends and loosened rolled joints are a workmanship issue, visible at the end face and in a tube pull, and the plug count is recorded honestly before re-tubing. Scale left at partitions and water box corners is a coverage issue: terminal difference recovers only partly, and the water box inspection plus the borescope locates it.
Non-cleaning causes are checked with the same discipline: air in-leakage, a weak air ejector, insufficient cooling water flow, and tube wall thinning from corrosion. None of these is fixed by cleaning again.
6. Evidence: what the acceptance file has to contain
A pre/post performance sheet at the same load, the deposit analysis and typing conclusion, the ball pass record, the tube pull and borescope photos, the coupon report and chloride log for any chemical stage, and the waste disposal and acceptance sign-off. With those six items the conclusion holds up and the next cleaning has a baseline.
FAQ
Is the ball pass test mandatory after condenser cleaning
Yes, but it proves the tubes are open, not that the walls are clean. Balls slightly under the tube ID passing through every tube show no blockage or trapped debris, yet a thin soft scale layer still lets them through, so the result is read together with terminal difference and a tube pull.
Terminal difference improved but vacuum did not, why
The cause is usually on the steam side, not in the tubes. Terminal difference only reflects how dirty the heat transfer surface is; air in-leakage, a weak air ejector or low gland steam all keep vacuum down, so a vacuum tightness test comes before any second cleaning.
Is there a code removal rate figure for water jetting
No. GB/T 25146-2010 covers chemical cleaning quality, and its removal and cleaning rates in Table 3 apply to chemical work only, so quoting them for pure jetting has no basis. Physical cleaning is judged by pre/post terminal difference, vacuum, water-side dP and a tube pull, with the ball pass record filed as evidence.
How many tubes are pulled and from where
Three to five tubes, covering the highest heat-flux zone, the air-cooling section and the run that needed the most plugs last time. A tube pull is destructive, so a plugging and re-tubing plan is ready first; the pulled sample shows residual scale thickness and any bell-mouth damage that end-face photos hide.
How often should performance be re-checked after cleaning
Weekly for the first month, then monthly, and the readings join the routine log once three months of trend are stable. Terminal difference climbs fastest in the high-load summer period, so re-checks are timed to high load and high cooling-water temperature; low-load readings tend to look better than the unit really is.
Related reading
- Heat exchanger cleaning acceptance criteria
- Condenser cleaning methods and selection
- Power plant condenser chemical cleaning
- All cleaning articles
Quality figures are quoted from GB/T 25146-2010, Acceptance specification for industrial equipment chemical cleaning quality (Table 2 corrosion rate and mass, Table 3 removal and cleaning rate, 5.2.9 chloride); jetting safety from GB/T 26148-2025, Safety specification for high-pressure water jetting; condenser chemical cleaning and film formation from DL/T 957-2017.
Condenser cleaning · verifying the result
📞 +86 18952832843
Danyang Blue Star Anti-corrosion Cleaning Co., Ltd. · member of the China Industrial Cleaning Association
Address: 98 Hongjiadai, Picheng, Danbei Town, Danyang, Jiangsu, China
Service coverage: Jiangsu (Nanjing, Suzhou, Wuxi, Changzhou, Zhenjiang, Yangzhou) · Zhejiang (Hangzhou, Ningbo) · Shanghai · Anhui · Shandong · Henan
© 2026 Danyang Blue Star Anti-corrosion Cleaning Co., Ltd. | Source: www.lanxingqingxi.com
